just got back from Episode III ~
some thoughts with no spoilers for those of you seeing it this weekend:
1.) i think george lucas got a clue and listened to advisors/fans this time.
2.) it's gratifying to see the saga "end" (makes you want to watch 4,5, and 6 again).
3.) serious flaws: continuity holes you can drive a mack truck through; missed opportunities for a few really cool images; one really lame cgi creature (he just couldn't resist, i guess).
4.) serious improvements: letting the actors act; toning down the cgi nonsense; no jar jar; great action sequences; some nice design tie-ins to 4, 5, 6.
i give it a thumb and a half up with a handful of caveats for the die-hard fans.
: D

some thoughts with no spoilers for those of you seeing it this weekend:
1.) i think george lucas got a clue and listened to advisors/fans this time.
2.) it's gratifying to see the saga "end" (makes you want to watch 4,5, and 6 again).
3.) serious flaws: continuity holes you can drive a mack truck through; missed opportunities for a few really cool images; one really lame cgi creature (he just couldn't resist, i guess).
4.) serious improvements: letting the actors act; toning down the cgi nonsense; no jar jar; great action sequences; some nice design tie-ins to 4, 5, 6.
i give it a thumb and a half up with a handful of caveats for the die-hard fans.
: D

Tags: